Seen from behind, a small figure reaches both hands across a large map spread on a table, toned blue-grey under a faint grid
PL.04Reaching across the map•FIELD STATION
FIELD STATION· 54.9°N 2.1°W
fieldstation.xyz
A talk by FIELD STATION

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?

Dr Doug Belshaw

Press H to see the keyboard shortcuts, S for the speaker notes

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
Where this comes fromFriends of the Earth•10 Feb 2025

Harnessing AI for environmental justice

policy.friendsoftheearth.uk
The top of the report's page on Friends of the Earth's policy site: the title Harnessing AI for environmental justice over a collage of people at old computers in a painted grassland, with a circuit board across the ground

Principles and practices to guide climate justice and digital rights campaigners in the responsible use of AI.

Written by

Laura Hilliger and Dr Doug Belshaw

We Are Open Cooperative

In collaboration with Mary Stevens, Friends of the Earth (England, Wales and Northern Ireland)

policy.friendsoftheearth.uk/reports/harnessing-ai-environmental-justice

Screenshot, 13 Nov 2026•Cover art: Hanna Barakat + AIxDESIGN & Archival Images of AI / Better Images of AI / Weaving Wires 2 / CC-BY 4.0

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
A cropped slice of a mosaic-like image of clouds, made of server and data center components, symbolizing the hidden physical infrastructure of cloud computing
Cloud Computing•Nadia Piet + AIxDESIGN
Harnessing AI for environmental justicePart 3

Seven principles

1

Curiosity around AI creates opportunities for better choices.

2

Transparency around usage, data and algorithms builds trust.

3

Holding tech companies and governments accountable leads to responsible action.

4

Including diverse voices strengthens decision making around AI.

5

Sustainability in AI systems helps reduce environmental impact and protect natural ecosystems.

6

Community collaboration in AI is key to planetary resilience.

7

Advocating with an intersectional approach supports humane AI.

From Part 3 of the report•Image: © Nadia Piet + AIxDESIGN & Archival Images of AI / Better Images of AI / Cloud Computing / CC-BY 4.0. Cropped

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•

Why do people default to Big AI?

Why do people default to Big AI? Three loops lock it in. Others push back. Convenience: using Big AI by default increases Big Tech's size and income, which pays for slicker defaults, UX and models, which means more use. Hidden costs: as Big Tech grows, AI is subsidised and built in, for now, so users see fewer of its costs (energy, water, carbon), so they use it more. Confidence: the more people use Big AI by default, the less confidence they have in alternatives, so the more they use Big AI. Backlash: as Big Tech grows, backlash grows after a delay, which builds confidence in alternatives and reduces default use. Commons: confidence in alternatives leads, after a delay, to more alternatives that work (co-op, local, municipal), which builds more confidence: a reinforcing loop that builds up the alternatives rather than Big AI. Regulation: backlash leads, after a delay, to disclosure rules, which make costs visible to users, so they use Big AI less by default. Use Big AI by default Big Tech size and income Slicker defaults, UX and models + + + CONVENIENCE AI subsidised and built in, for now Costs users can see energy, water, carbon + − − HIDDEN COSTS Confidence in alternatives − − CONFIDENCE Backlash against Big Tech + + BACKLASH Alternatives that work co-op, local, municipal + + COMMONS Disclosure rules + + REGULATION + more leads to more − more leads to less delay

Developed from an insight brief by Mary Stevens, Co-Lead of the Friends of the Earth Experiments Team

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?Thank you

Questions?

Where could we intervene in this system?

Lower leverage Higher leverage
WHEN

Delays

When could the pushback arrive sooner?

WHERE

Loops

Where could a loop be weakened, or strengthened?

WHAT

Information

What do people need to be able to see?

WHO

Rules

Who sets the rules, and who could change them?

HOW

Self-organisation

How could alternatives grow by themselves?

WHY

Goals

Why are we using AI for this at all?

FIELD STATION· 54.9°N 2.1°W

Dr Doug Belshaw

contact@fieldstation.xyz

fieldstation.xyz

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
Backup slidesClick one to open it
Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
AExample•When it runsActs on hidden costs

Run it later, when the grid is cleaner

GreenPT•carbon-aware timing

greenpt.com/carbon-aware-api
GreenPT's illustrative grid forecast over 24 hours: 238 grams of CO2e per kilowatt-hour at 16:00, 123 grams at the best start, 02:00

Give it a deadline and it picks a cleaner time to run.

A 45-minute job due by 08:00 has about half the carbon if it starts at 02:00.

GreenPT’s own illustration. Early access.

Which of your tasks could wait?

Now Soon Eventually

greenpt.com/carbon-aware-api•CO2e: all greenhouse gases, counted as CO2

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
BExample•Where it runsActs on how use feeds Big Tech

Same energy, different carbon

EcoLogits•AI writing one email

4.17 watt-hours per email, in all three

Sweden
0.25 g CO2e
UK
1.01 g CO2e
Poland
2.55 g CO2e

Ten times the carbon in Poland as in Sweden.

Closer to home

Tiles

An assistant you own. Runs open models on your own computer.

llamafile

From Mozilla.ai. Runs a model as a single file on your machine.

Exmouth

A small data centre at the leisure centre. Its heat warms the pool.

Estimates: calculator.ecologits.ai (Code Carbon), 4 Nov 2026•tiles.run•docs.mozilla.ai•Exmouth: AFP, June 2023

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
CExample•Whose AI it isActs on alternatives that work

Treat AI like a utility

“Co-operative models could work for smaller-scale infrastructure. Municipal ownership could work for community datacentres.”

Peter Wilson•4 Feb 2026•his own views

Alternatives you can try today

inference.coop

A member-governed co-op for AI. Open models, from $5 a month.

co/core

An experiment: members share spare computing power on their Macs.

Alpha

Free public AI from AI Potluck, an initiative of the non-profit Current AI. Its X-ray shows which model answered and where it ran.

“AI Growth Zones: Gift Horse or Trojan Horse?”, peteski22.github.io•inference.coop•cocore.dev•alpha.aipotluck.org

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
DCode CarbonHeard about at MozFest

Measure your own AI’s carbon

codecarbon.io
Code Carbon home page: a French non-profit building free, open-source tools. Two cards: CodeCarbon for local compute emissions, EcoLogits for GenAI API impacts.

Computers you run

CodeCarbon measures the power, then applies your grid’s carbon.

AI services you call

EcoLogits estimates each request. Its calculator is behind the figures on backup B.

Free, open source•mostly for developers

codecarbon.io

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
EPublic AI•AI Potluckalpha.aipotluck.org

Alpha’s X-ray shows the hidden choices

A free AI assistant from AI Potluck, an initiative by Current AI, a non-profit.

People bring the open models, datasets and tools. Its X-ray shows what happened behind each answer.

alpha.aipotluck.org

alpha.aipotluck.org
Alpha's X-ray panel for one answer: checked for safety, nothing flagged; read 6 web results; the model was Mistral Medium 3.5, made by Mistral AI in France; it ran on Mistral AI in France; the data is stored by Current AI in Alpha's own database, and guest conversations are deleted after 30 days

Alpha’s X-ray panel for one answer, 5 Nov 2026•AI Potluck, an initiative by Current AI•aipotluck.org

Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
FWhat people ask AI for•Bearing

Only 26 of 354 Bearing tasks were chat

Bearing public dataset v2.1•354 tasks, 12 Apr to 2 Nov 2026•findbearing.org/data

354 tasks people brought to Bearing, one square each A grid of 354 squares. 26 blue squares are conversation. The other 328 are jobs: 171 solid squares need an answer now and 157 outlined squares can wait. CHAT JOBS ONE SQUARE, ONE TASK 26 328 230 of them recurring 171 need an answer now 157 can wait
Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•
GCredits and sources
  • The report. Harnessing AI for environmental justice, Friends of the Earth, 10 Feb 2025. Laura Hilliger and Dr Doug Belshaw, in collaboration with Mary Stevens
  • Picture on the principles slide. Cloud Computing, © Nadia Piet + AIxDESIGN & Archival Images of AI / Better Images of AI, CC-BY 4.0 (creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0). One of the report’s pictures, cropped
  • PL.04Reaching across the map. FIELD STATION
  • Report cover art in the screenshot. Weaving Wires 2, Hanna Barakat + AIxDESIGN & Archival Images of AI / Better Images of AI, CC BY 4.0
  • The loop diagram is developed from an insight brief by Mary Stevens, Co-Lead of the Friends of the Earth Experiments Team.
  • ‘Just enough’ is Rachel Coldicutt’s framing.
  • Screenshots taken 4, 5 and 13 Nov 2026 from greenpt.com, codecarbon.io, alpha.aipotluck.org and policy.friendsoftheearth.uk
  • Carbon per email. EcoLogits, calculator.ecologits.ai, 4 Nov 2026. Estimates.
  • Quote on the utility slide. Peter Wilson, “AI Growth Zones: Gift Horse or Trojan Horse?”, 4 Feb 2026. His own views.
  • Bearing data. Bearing Public Dataset v2.1, CC BY-NC 4.0
  • Exmouth data centre. AFP via Tech Xplore, June 2023
  • Leverage points. Donella Meadows, “Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System”, 1999
  • Carbon-aware timing. GreenPT, greenpt.com/carbon-aware-api. The chart is their own illustration.
  • Tools named on A to C. tiles.run, docs.mozilla.ai, inference.coop, cocore.dev, alpha.aipotluck.org
Environmental Justice: Why do people default to Big AI?FIELD STATION LTD•